
Bimini Bay in Apollo Beach, Florida
Bimini Bay is a small, gated coastal community of roughly 157 homesites in Apollo Beach, and it looks like nowhere else around here. Key West-inspired architecture, brightly colored exteriors, metal roofs, front porches and paver driveways, all on golf-cart-friendly streets. More than half the homesites sit on saltwater canals leading to Tampa Bay.
What is Bimini Bay like?
The Key West styling is not a marketing line here. It is the whole streetscape. Colorful homes, tropical landscaping, ponds with fountains, and a scale small enough that people actually know each other. The community throws block parties. It is gated but not guard-gated, and it is not a 55-plus community.



What amenities does Bimini Bay have?
Bimini Bay is intentionally modest on amenities, the draw is the setting and the water access, not a resort campus.
- Community swimming pool with a pool deck, lounge seating and shaded areas
- Clubhouse and community pavilion
- Gated entrance
- Landscaped common areas and ponds with fountains
- Walking paths and sidewalks
- Playground
- Golf-cart-friendly streets
You will see other sites list a fitness center, tennis courts, a marina or a community boat ramp. I could not verify any of those, so I do not advertise them. If one of those matters to you, ask me and I will confirm before you tour.




The waterfront question: this is the important one
Bimini Bay is really two products sharing one gate. Interior and pond-view homes are one market; direct-access canal homes are another, and the gap between them is enormous. Two homes of nearly the same size on the same street can be several hundred thousand dollars apart based purely on water access and dock infrastructure.
Canal-front properties here can offer direct, bridge-free access to Tampa Bay. Some already have a private dock and boat lift. Others have only a seawall, which leaves the dock and lift for you to permit and build. Canal depth, vessel draft, lift capacity and turning room all have to be checked property by property.
And to be clear about something buyers get wrong: living in Bimini Bay does not come with a boat slip. There is no community marina or ramp. Water access belongs to the individual property.
What do homes cost in Bimini Bay?
- Approximately 157 homesites; single-family homes only
- Developed from roughly 2006 through 2023, with a few vacant or preconstruction opportunities remaining
- Generally 3 to 5 bedrooms, about 2,000 to 3,400 sq. ft., with some custom homes approaching or exceeding 4,000
- Interior and pond-view homes, and true canal-front boating homes, all inside the same gate
Interior and pond-view resales generally run from the high $300s into the upper $500s. Standard canal-front homes land in the mid $600s to upper $800s, and larger custom waterfront homes run from around $900,000 upward. Averages for this community are misleading. Ask me what is actually available and what it should cost.
For a direct comparison, Bimini Bay waterfront homes sold for a median of $580,000 from January 1 to November 2, 2026, and sellers got a median of 98% of their asking price (Stellar MLS). My waterfront communities guide lines that up against MiraBay, Symphony Isles and Andalucía.
What are the HOA fees in Bimini Bay, and is there a CDD?
Bimini Bay has no CDD, which is unusual in this part of Apollo Beach and a real cost advantage over most newer communities nearby. It does have a mandatory HOA covering the gate, pool, clubhouse and common areas.
Published HOA figures for Bimini Bay conflict badly, recent records show quarterly assessments anywhere from roughly $350 to $510, and portal listings often show numbers that do not reconcile. Dues may vary by phase or property type. Verify the figure for the specific property through the HOA and the estoppel; do not trust a number off a listing site. I will get it for you.
Where is Bimini Bay?
Bimini Bay sits directly across from Apollo Beach Elementary, a highly rated public school that is now expanding through middle school. That is a real draw for families, though school assignment should always be confirmed for a specific address.
It is blocks from the Manatee Viewing Center, the sea turtle rehabilitation center and the Apollo Beach Nature Preserve, with waterfront restaurants, marinas and public boat ramps close by, quick access to Apollo Beach Boulevard, and reasonable reach to US 41 and I-75.
What should you check before buying in Bimini Bay?
Bimini Bay is west of US 41 and includes canal-front property, so flood and insurance diligence matters more than it does inland. Verify the FEMA flood zone and get the elevation certificate. Get an insurance quote before your inspection period expires, and ask whether the seller’s flood policy is assumable. Have the seawall, dock and lift inspected separately from the house, and confirm who is responsible for maintaining the seawall. Read the HOA restrictions on exterior colors, docks, lifts, fencing, parking and rentals.
None of that is a reason to avoid Bimini Bay. It is a reason to buy here with someone who knows to check.
Thinking about Bimini Bay?
I live and work in Apollo Beach and sell throughout Florida. Whether you want a canal home with a lift or an interior home with a private pool, I can tell you what is available, what the water access really is, and what the HOA actually costs.
Still weighing your options? Compare this community against the others in the Apollo Beach and Ruskin neighborhoods guide, or see how it stacks up against the area’s other waterfront communities.
Are there homes for sale in Bimini Bay right now?
Yes. I have 567 Bimini Bay Boulevard listed, a gated Bimini Bay pool home built in 2019. If boating is part of your plan, tell me about your boat, since Bimini Bay has a bridge to pass under on the way to the bay and that matters for taller boats.
Homes here can go quickly, so if one has already sold by the time you read this, I would still love to hear from you. You can search every home for sale around Apollo Beach, or use the form at the bottom of this page to tell me what you are hoping to find in Bimini Bay, and I will send you new Bimini Bay listings as soon as they come on the market.
